The silver lining — for global business — inside the Andersen conviction and its overturning

At the end of this day of unplanned Andersen reunions and impromptu alumni meetings,  the positive elements of this entire episode are clearer than ever.  Not just for the lives upended by the indictment and the conviction nor for the empty rejoicing of a reputation less tarnished but for those affected by the churn.  That means all of us who conduct business.

Four good things.

Sarbanes-Oxley and the daylighting of the back office, the back room and maybe even the university club.

Less self absorption and more introspection on the topics of accountability, responsibility and personal motivation.

A higher — and more specific — burden of proof in the prosecution of actions as well as intent.

Andersen values alive and well.

Despite the betrayal and the missteps, the benign neglect and deliberate upheaval, the achievements, performance, competitiveness, work ethic and service orientation of thousands were not lost.  These things never are.  Instead, they are imbedded in organizations the world over.  Companies and governments and foundations and schools are the beneficiaries of a professional energy that has long been the secret sauce of the Andersen alum.  Fabu, I say. 

Andersen conviction overturned — vindicates the organization but it should not vindicate those who enabled the event

What a way to start the day here on the west coast.  News that the Supreme Court has unanimously overturned the conviction of Andersen in the Enron case.

This is an enormous vindication of the majority of the people who embodied the vision and values of the venerable organization — but not of the few managers who enabled Andersen’s destruction.  Would that the last teams of managing partners had the dedication to the principles that guided Andersen for decades.  Their interpretation of legacy extended only to what they naively believed was the measure of success:  belonging to the same club of clout their avaricious clients had erected and whose membership they controlled.

I wrote about this two years ago in a short piece published by HARVARD BUSINESS REVIEW.  The fact that the managers whose mismanagement brought Andersen down will soothe their wounded psyches with this reversal of the conviction is the only downside of today’s events.  Had they seen fit to act as stewards of Andersen’s focus on professional standards, Enron never would have happened to Andersen.  Like the other clients whose antics and shenanigans were uncovered by Andersen, Enron would have been fired as a client and its leaders exposed for who they were long before Enron imploded and Andersen exploded.

One more thing before the next blog:  this verdict is no indictment of the noble effort to prosecute white collar crime.  It is, however, a word of warning about persecuting the innocent and making scapegoats when the prosecution of a few individuals will do.  We should identify the truly guilty and learn from their mistakes.