Marketing’s human resource

CPRI, the firm that provides interim marketing and creative insourcing professionals to FORTUNE 500 clients, today announced the results of a study it conducted.  The subject:  the communications gap between the corporate HR and marketing functions. 

Some highlights.  45 percent of the marketing execs believe that their biggest challenge is having HR unearth qualified candidates.  50 percent of the marketing execs are planning to hire this year.  And 52 percent of the marketing execs believe that HR does not understand the skill sets Marketing needs on its team.

Scary.  So I want to help close the communication gap. 

First, HR functionaries must become more open to what CPRI calls contingent players — getting advice and support on an as-needed basis without staffing-up unnecessarily.  And second, whatever the nature of the hire — permanent or contingent — I believe there are five qualities, above and beyond industry and project experience, that HR should seek when filling a marketing position.

A sense of urgency.  As soon as marketing types act as if their work is mission-critical, the rest of the organization will start paying attention.  Look for people who think their work is too important to lolly gag over.

A dedication to selling.  Marketing is only as good as the support it offers to the sales force.  The reason marketing exists in an organization is to help sell product and inspire all stakeholders — that means customers and employees — to appreciate what the literature and talking points say is so different about the company’s product or service.

Writing ability.  If the organization can’t decide between two equally qualified candidates, and the only difference is writing ability, pick the one with writing ability.  It means he or she can think — and thinking means they have the ability to strategize as well as execute.

Work ethic.  A business school professor once said that the hardest working business majors went into the accounting and finance programs, not marketing.  That was one professor’s experience, and I’ve seen many hardworking marketers, but this should be enough to make anyone double-check.

An aversion to waste.  Years ago, I happened upon a staffer, MBA in marketing, clearing out his files.  The papers were held together with tons of expensive binder clips.  He was not removing them.  The papers were in expensive file and hanging folders.  He was tossing them, too.  I often wonder whether this individual can read an agency invoice or evaluate work product or tell the difference between powerful copy and superfluous verbiage.  Because at that time, he wasn’t thinking about the cost of anything.  When you’re not worried about the waste, you’re not worried about the cost.

Meatballs and differentiation

The assignment of co-writing and project-managing Cooking with My Sisters has moved into the completed column, making room for more recent gigs.  Yet the comments of colleagues who have read the book and are using the stories and recipes remind me — almost daily — of the synergy that abides between every endeavor.

Take meatballs.  My mother’s and grandmother’s meatballs-and-sauce have been known to change lives.  I am not exaggerating.  Folks who have dined at their tables report that this dish forges a connection between the old world and the new.  And it prompts not just compliments but questions.  How my mother learned to make the dish from her mother-in-law, what role it has in the family cuisine, whether they make it differently from other women in the family, the secret ingredients [there are none — the secret is cooking the meatballs and the sauce together — we don’t make the meatballs without the sauce and vice versa].  The answers given by my mother and grandmother are the factors that distinguish our family from the folks next door.

As a result, meatballs really did change one life.  Mine.

In working with my family to articulate the recipe that had never been written down, I came full circle to the realization of where and when my professional life began.  The support and counsel I’ve been offering to great clients have always been centered in helping them discover and deploy what is authentically, richly their own — in the way of intellectual capital as well as product or service features.  Along comes this book project, and I am reminded that the theme of differentiation played in my life long before I shepherded some slides for Michael Porter and my boss, Victor Millar, through the audiovisual department at Andersen Worldwide.  It began in the family kitchen, watching my mother concoct the sauce while absorbing her guidance to "be different — don’t try to be like everyone else — show them who you are — everyone will be better for it."

So it was satisfying when a colleague in the M&A sphere reminded me that when he backs a company or combines organizations, he is looking for the secret sauce [see May 31 post, too] that will sustain the new entity.  And he’s not even Italian.

49ers scandal points to expanding professional crisis — in management as well as marketing

Is anyone really shocked that a PR manager got the brilliant idea to communicate with his internal audience along the lowest common denominator?

The denominator itself is disgusting.  Don’t even need to dignify the interests of the PR guy’s audience or his apologists with any discussion.  The critical issues — and of great significance to any business — are to be found in the back story.

If it’s true that the team’s owners and managers only took action when threatened with public exposure, to the media and the league, after knowing of the tape’s existence for months, more than the PR manager’s judgment is in question.

If the PR manager’s counsel on the question of the coach’s effectiveness outweighed that of professionals with some expertise in leading teams on the field, playbooks and talent, more than the PR manager’s power is in question.

If with all the PR expertise out there this is all the 49ers could find to advise them on visibility — and teach the players something about what constitutes a positive image — more than the PR manager’s credentials is in question.

Businesses and their leaders must realize that in claiming the bully pulpit they have a responsibility to elevate discussion and push standards of behavior ever higher, not lower.  They must retain professionals who aid them in accomplishing this objective, not convince them that the content of a video like this is effective, much less funny.  And they need people who focus the outbound messages and inbound training for the organization on the business at hand, not themselves and their apparent desire for stardom or coziness with the other employees.

Of course, maybe this is just about the pugilists taking their Neanderthal-ic field rules and trying to get the rest of us to play by them.  I hope the new PR manager can figure out a better way to make that happen, if that is indeed the strategy.  We’ll take that on as well.